Justin Allagier freely admitted in an interview with SiriusXM NASCAR Radio last week at JR Motorsports Fan Day that he was set on retiring at the end of the 2026 NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series season.
Then, he started winning — a lot — and everybody’s been trying to change his mind since.
First, it was his team. Then, his wife, Ashley. Then, it was his pastor.
“We get ready to get off the phone, and [Allgaier’s pastor] goes ‘Alright, well, when you win that championship at the end of this year, I don’t want to hear any talk about you quitting or retiring, because the only way to win two in a row is to win the first one,’” Allgaier told SiriusXM NASCAR Radio. “I went home, I called my wife immediately, and I was like, ‘Did you get God involved in this?’”
He followed this revelation up with another stellar performance at Nashville Superspeedway, leading 50 laps on his way to his fourth win of the season. His lead in the O’Reilly points now sits at 179 points over defending series champion Jesse Love. For perspective, if you took away his 225 stage points — the most of any driver in the series this season — he’d still be third in the standings.
His 29th-place finish at Charlotte Motor Speedway prior to Nashville was his lone finish outside the top 10 on a drafting track. He has more top-fives (11) than he had in all of 2024 when he became series champion. If the season ended today, his average finish of 7.9 would easily be the best of his career.
The run is, unsurprisingly, something Allgaier has called “probably the most fun I’ve had in my career.”
It’s also ruining his retirement plans.
“I actually bought a house if that gives you any consolation,” Allgaier said after his win Saturday (May 30). “I bought a house in Illinois. The neighbors are still super confused as to what’s going on.”
So why on earth would he want to retire? For starters, Allgaier turns 40 this week. For more than half of his life, Allgaier has been racing in a national stock car series, be it ARCA or NASCAR. Not to mention, there’s not a whole lot left for him to prove. After years as one of the most dependable drivers of the O’Reilly Series with dozens of wins to his credit, he pulled off one of the greatest comebacks in the past quarter-century of the sport when he overcame two penalties to win the 2024 championship at Phoenix Raceway.
But when he captured that championship that eluded him for so long, he practically found another gear. In the past year and a half since, Allgaier has seven wins, 26 top fives and nearly 1,500 laps led in a time in his career, as he said at the season-opening race at Daytona International Speedway back in 2025, where he felt next to no pressure when he arrived at the race track.
How could he stop now? For all the legends of the sport, who was the last guy to say they went out on top or, better yet, at the peak of their performance? For crying out loud, Allgaier went and did a triathlon the day after his win at Nashville.
It isn’t even winning, or the constant persuasion from team and family, that’s created the most change in his outlook. At least not recently.
“Look, the last two weeks have been really tough for everyone,” Allgaier said, alluding to the passing of Kyle Busch. “Not that that’s weighed on my decision, but it’s made me value why I love this sport so much, why I wake up in the morning and do the things I do and how fragile life really is.”
“I’ve enjoyed being around this garage. There’s nothing like the people in this garage. Whether it’s the media, the fans, the teams, the spotters, there’s nothing like this in my life outside the four walls of this racetrack.”
So, we’re close to halfway through the 2026 season and the not-quite-retirement tour of Allgaier. Where does he sit on a decision? Right now, he says it’s more likely he’ll be back next year rather than hanging it up.
Great news for JRM and Allgaier fans. Bad news for anybody in the O’Reilly Series.
James Krause joined Frontstretch in March 2024 as a contributor. Krause was born and raised in Illinois and graduated from Northern Illinois University. He currently works in Fort Wayne, Indiana covering minor league, college and high school sports. Outside of racing, Krause loves to keep up with football, music, anime and video games.
Thanks for choosing to comment on this article. A name and email address are required to post a comment. The email address is not publicly visible or shared. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.