Race Weekend Central

The All-Star Race Is Not the Problem

This weekend, the Cup Series returns to Texas Motor Speedway for the All-Star Race.  I havenʻt checked, and nor will I bother, to see how many articles are being written about how the race is a waste of time, or the format is wrong, or that something about something is not right.  In that scenario, it is probably something about Kyle Busch.

If anyone seems to encounter a lionʻs share of the vitriol from NASCAR fans, Busch is the one.  Sure, Joey Logano has also become a favorite target but the narrative around him seems different like he is more of a wanker than anything resembling the dubious devil driving the No. 18.

But really, good for both of them.  They must be doing something right if lots of people not only know their names but also hold opinions about them. Never mind if those opinions are actually based on having ever spent time with either driver.  Have you had dinner with Logano or Busch?  Played golf?  Discussed the data points of speed and how it relates to constructed notions of intuition?

Everything is a facade.  They are real people but who knows anything real about them other than those who are closest.  Twitter, Instagram, Meta, Reddit, rumors, 4chan, whatever, if any of that truly offers insight, that would be a lovely notion.  The construct, however, is what matters, and the same notion matters regarding the so-called All-Star Race.

See also
Only Yesterday: The Day NASCAR's Past & Future Met in The Winston

What makes the ASR such a complete and unknowable thing is that it exists only in our collective imagination.  Many will turn in to watch millionaires race with the prospect of winning another million if that makes sense.  Others will spend time watching the event because of habit, that as fans the normal cyclic rhythm of watching cars go in circles is familiar and enjoyable.  And because it is a Saturday night, thereʻs a solid excuse to drink some beverages and enjoy spending time with the TV family known as NASCAR.  And some will be genuinely interested because performance in the race does actually offer some insight as to who the best drivers are.

Recognize that seven-time champ Jimmie Johnson stands as the all-time leader of wins for the ASR with four.  Dale Earnhardt and Jeff Gordon are situated with three wins apiece.  For a race that began in 1985, there is a certain amount of relevance in understanding excellence through the ASR, but just maybe not enough.

Even the fact that the two most recent winners of the race, Chase Elliott (2020) and Kyle Larson (2021) won championships during the seasons they grabbed victory says little.  The win is not necessarily a harbinger of hoisting the big trophy at the end of the season.  So, what, if any is the point of whatʻs going on here?

The truth is, the ASR is more of a challenging existence than it needs to be.  For starters, how about we all recognize that every single Cup race is an all-star race.  The drivers with the most active wins all race every weekend.  The drivers who have won recent championships all show up.  So aside from the goofy formats, nothing really seems all that All-Starry.

The focus here is not necessarily on killing the ASR but rather that if the event is going to continue to exist (and, of course, it will continue to exist because it is easy money for many involved).  The big thing that comes to mind is that the sport needs to figure out the best venue for holding the event.

Charlotte had been the mainstay, hosting the ASR for nearly the entirety of its existence.  Then in 2020, things changed.  Bristol produced a tame result for something that is supposed to be wild and chaotic.  The next year the ASR bounced to Texas, and the truth is, NASCAR solved a problem that may not have existed by trying to fix it with a venue that offered little comparative value to Charlotte.

See also
Did You Notice?: A Dozen NASCAR Tracks Still Have 2 Cup Dates. Should They?

In this weekʻs DYN, Bowles discussed how Kansas and Texas have turned into problematic tracks on the schedule, ones deserving scrutiny for having two race dates on the schedule.   The evidence showcases how Texas has really become a challenging market with disappointing attendance numbers.

Empirical data suggests offers the notion that when there is evidence to support an argument then the argument is valid. In this case, not only is Texas not worthy of having two race dates, there should be suspicion that there is little to no value in holding the ASR there at all.  There is every reason to believe that NASCAR is trying to help the track out by ʻgivingʻ it the ASR and to the appeal of no one.

So what to do?

First, ditch Texas.  Not only does the track offer no historical significance but it also has not provided the theater for exciting competition that many hope for when bothering to watch the ASR.  Second, do the smart thing…go to Miami.

If the recent F1 race in Miami has offered anything, it is that the city is meant to host over-hyped events for the benefit of the sport involved.  Was there any reason for the Miami GP to register as high as it did in ratings and attention?  Not really.  It was a mid-season race with a new car on a new track where the beauty of the event was the newness and hype.

NASCAR should take a page from what F1 offered and figure out a way to make Homestead the place to be and sell the ASR as a spectacle, bringing in the stars and making a spectacle of things.  If F1 can make s a proverbial splash with a fake marina then NASCAR can surely figure out a way to make Homestead seem like it is the Met Gala.  This is not about the racing but the limited ideologies of how to make the sport seem like the fascinating wonderful monster that it is.

The ASR used to matter at one point.  It used to be a convergence of star power and horsepower but it has been relegated to an afterthought, a mere curio on the calendar.  Bringing new life to the event requires more than just tinkering with the format, it requires understanding that the unconventional might be the way to go.

About the author

Ava Lader headshot photo

As a writer and editor, Ava anchors the Formula 1 coverage for the site, while working through many of its biggest columns. Ava earned a Masters in Sports Studies at UGA and a PhD in American Studies from UH-Mānoa. Her dissertation Chased Women, NASCAR Dads, and Southern Inhospitality: How NASCAR Exports The South is in the process of becoming a book.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sally Baker

One of the things that made the race fun was including the teams that are so important to success. the pit crew challenge, held on an actual PIT ROAD with the car screeching to a stop really showcased the guys who work so hard and are so important. Being held in Charlotte, it gave the families of those who work behind the scenes a chance to cheer for their guys. The family, country fair atmosphere made it so much more fun. Too bad they don’t still have the competition.


Seems there was a truck driver competition a time or two?. I understand the Pit crew and truck driver things are NOT big draws but they were fun(to me). I think the Charolette location allows the teams to ‘work from home’ which is nice. But I got tired of Charolette as well.

My personal thought is to make it it an open weekend on the schedule. All Star and playoffs are stick and ball things. The do not fit well in the the NASCAR box.


Give Texas a chance this year. Has the track sucked for the last 4 years? Yes. But this car has provided some of the best intermediate racing we’ve seen since 2014, a year where the cars were going faster than Japanese bullet trains into the corner. If the racing Sunday night is as good as what we saw at Auto Club, Vegas, Dover, Darlington(which is great regardless) and Kansas? Keep it. Speaking of how good this car has raced on intermediate tracks, that has me really pumped for the Coke 600 for the first time in a long time. 2020 and 2021’s 600 weren’t very good, but if we get 600 miles of the racing we saw at the tracks listed above? It’s gonna be a treat!


Someone else give Texas a chance, cause I’m not. We will miss most of the good action anyway and listen to ridiculous nonsense. I could care less about that race.


I like your thinking. Miami would be a great location for the All Star Race. And sell Texas to a developer. The fall race competes with F1 and Football. Guess who wins. Sell the property.
An all star race in Miami is a winner. I also would consider one year at Homestead and one year on the street course, or make all of it on the street course. Great idea.


“Others will spend time watching the event because of habit”

It is an “EVENT’ not a “RACE”! And NA$CAR continues to treat it as another example of Brian’s product..


Ever heard the term “sporting event” before? There’s a reason people call it that. I really hope it hasn’t taken you this long to realize NASCAR is a business as well as a sporting league. It’s been that way since 1972 if not before.


Hey Stubby! Haven’t you realized NA$CAR hasn’t had a real “race” for years!


And haven’t you realized that everything isn’t rigged or a conspiracy theory yet?


Well Stubby, I guess you haven’t seen any PHDs (phantom debris cautions).


Those don’t happen 5 times a race though. They happen maybe 2 or 3 times a year, and hardly ever more than once a race, leaving 33 “Non rigged” races a year.


Hey Stubby! You haven’t been watching long enough. “Debris” that couldn’t be seen used to happen 5 times per example of Brian’s product, especially when certain drivers needed a caution or to set up a GWC for the game 7 moment so they could pull away for the last two laps. The drivers were even expecting them.

Bill B

“And because it is a Saturday night, thereʻs a solid excuse to drink some beverages and enjoy spending time with the TV family known as NASCAR. ”

Didn’t check the date Ava? We all assume it will be Saturday night but, surprise!…It’s on Sunday night because NASCAR doesn’t give a flop about their fans having to work the next day. Those that watch will be making a choice between a happy Monday or a sleep deprived Monday. If they dare drink some beverages they will be further jeopardizing their performance on Monday and risk making it a “hungover Monday”. As usual, no common sense applied to work symbiotically with their fanbase, just more of this is the way it’s gonna be, deal with it. Well, many will deal with it by skipping it altogether. It really isn’t that great of an event anyway.


In Nascars defense, the main race is only 100 laps

Bill B

Regardless, if you have a job and are responsible, you have lost the opportunity to get together with friends and pound beverages.


if you wanna do that, watch the truck race friday night. Most of them seem drunk already anyways.


I agree, the “All Star” race really is just another race, albeit one that doesn’t give points toward the Championship (or even count toward making “The Chase”).

Thus, I think NASCAR needs to step out of the box, and for one week a year, provide something that hearkens back to their roots and gives the auto manufacturers an opportunity to showcase their product. Yeah, I’m suggesting they go to Bristol or Martinsville (maybe even a short road course?) in bone stock NA V6 cars (to keep it somewhat fair for Toyota)!

Here’s how it would play out. Let’s say each manufacturer gets 4 entries to the “All Star” race. Thus, the drivers selected for each manufacturer would have to be the best performer for said manufacturer. So you’d have 12 cars (maybe 15 if you expanded to 5 per manufacturer) duking it out on a small track – in specially prepared bone stock cars. They would be specially prepared for safety – add roll cage, racing seat, fuel cell, remove glass, etc. but run otherwise stock. So it’s more of an airport rental car battle royale!

Pit crews would have to use the factory jack and lug nut wrench – after taking them out of the trunk, and the stop wouldn’t be over until they securely put them back in place after the service. OK, OK, I’ll relent on that as it’s a bit over the top. They can use a hydraulic jack, but MUST use manual 4-way lug wrenches!

I know I’m crazy, but I think this could be a fun event. It would be different, and actually give the younger generations a glimpse of how NASCAR began.


Let the crew chief or driver’s wife or girlfriend drive the cars.

Share via