Race Weekend Central

NASCAR Mailbox: What Should NASCAR Do With The All-Star Race?

The All-Star Race kind of feels like The Clash to me: unnecessary and lacking luster. What should NASCAR do with it? – Brodie L., Fargo, N.D.

I wish I knew, Brodie. I wish I knew.

I miss the electric feel of the event. When fans came down to Charlotte in droves and visited team shops, organizations had fan days, pit crew competitions were a thing, the $1 million felt like it was significant … those days feel so far removed.

It feels like a different era (well, I guess it is) of the All-Star Race being just that: a race. No stages, no package changes, no inverts, no random draws, no mandatory stops. Just line ’em up, race and go home. Could you imagine?

Honestly, I don’t think I can. That’s just a product of NASCAR racing and society in 2021. Something needs to be different, needs to be headline-grabbing, needs to be short enough to keep people’s attention. Hence the 2021 rules for the ASR (which I’m not going to try and recite).

See also
Waid's World: Surprise, Unheralded Winner Is Just 1 Part of All-Star Race Lore

It also comes at a strange time. More than half the regular season is over, the summer stretch is in full force, the venue is, well, undesirable in terms of the on-track product and it seems that there’s just no hype for the event itself.

The ASR should be something that speaks for itself: a one-off race that gets drivers and fans alike excited. But in recent years, all of that is lacking. How to fix it is the (no pun intended) million-dollar question.

North Wilkesboro Speedway would be cool, but is unrealistic for at least the next few years. So is Rockingham Speedway. Bristol Motor Speedway happened last year, Martinsville Speedway would be cool, as would Darlington Raceway. … There are endless options.

See also
Sky Is Limit for North Wilkesboro After Newfound Hope

If I had it my way, I’d have it cycle through multiple local tracks in the greater North Carolina area, allowing minimal travel for teams (and less of a financial burden) and the potential to race at local short tracks that NASCAR deems race-ready (from a safety and competition standpoint).

But it may be too good to be true. All I know is that something needs to be done to the All-Star Race, I just wish I knew what that something is.

How many wins is realistic for Kyle Larson this season? – Particia I., Elk Grove, Calif.

I mean, realistically speaking, he can win all 20 remaining races. It won’t happen, but that’s how good Kyle Larson is right now.

With four more road course races, conventional wisdom would be to pencil him in for at least one win there, given his speed at the Daytona International Speedway road course, Circuit of the Americas and Sonoma Raceway this season. At least one or two more intermediate victories, given his results at those tracks thus far, and probably one at a short track/superspeedway.

So probably at least four more wins. But that seems so low, doesn’t it? The No. 5 team was in their own stratosphere on Sunday (June 6) at Sonoma. And they realistically could have won the last six (!) races.

At Kansas Speedway, he led a race-high 132 laps before a late incident with Ryan Blaney relegated him to 19th. At Darlington, he finished second. At Dover International Speedway, he finished second after leading 327 laps. At COTA, he finished second after rain helped teammate Chase Elliott grab the win (if it didn’t rain, Larson was in line for the W). Charlotte Motor Speedway, he won, and Sonoma, he won.

That’s a month and a half of races that Larson has or easily could have won if circumstances played out just a tad differently. Hendrick Motorsports clearly has more horsepower than their competition, and their driver stable is packing a punch every single week.

See also
Up to Speed: Will a Teammate Battle Decide the 2021 NASCAR Championship?

However many wins Larson does earn this season, you can just add them to the list (an already extensive one at that). All “Yung Money” does is win, and the world is seeing it on display so far this season.

About the author

Davey is in his fifth season with Frontstretch and currently serves as a multimedia editor and reporter. He authors the "NASCAR Mailbox" column, spearheads the site's video content and hosts the Frontstretch Podcast weekly. He's covered the K&N Pro Series and ARCA extensively for NASCAR.com and currently serves as an associate producer for SiriusXM NASCAR Radio and production assistant for NBC Sports Washington. Follow him on Twitter @DaveyCenter.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Share this article

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Matt Griffin

-What to do with the ASR?
If the plan is to run the dirt configuration at Bristol next year, per Marcus Smith and SMI, then perhaps that may be the venue of choice to make the All-Star a true spectacle again. Also make it a charity event, with an equal amount of the winners purse going to that drivers’ cause.

-How many races will Larson win?
I’m going with 9. A final four spot is all but assured.


I like the all star dirt track idea. The all star race isn’t going away anytime soon (or ever), and you might as well give a gimmick race a gimmick track.

Plus we can have two traditional Bristol races back on schedule

A Different Steve

I like this idea ONLY IF they also keep the 2 pavement races at Bristol. Sacrificing a regular oval race there with a dirt race leaves a sour taste in my mouth considering how very few short tracks are on the schedule as it is.

Bob Brown

SRX on Saturday is much more exciting than ASR for me…feels like we’re heading into off weekend for cup from where I sit


Can they recreate the pit road competition…on a real pit road? If they use Bristol it could work!


I think they should make it a true “Throwback” race. Give the manufacturers a race in which factory produced cars (with only safety gear and racing tires added) get to duke it out just like they did 60 years ago. For a bit of parity, you’d have to make the Mustangs and Camaros run the V-6 configuration unless Toyota starts putting a V8 in the Camry. Race at any of the tracks that are a mile or less where speeds won’t get too crazy/unsafe. Bring back “Win on Sunday, Sell on Monday!”.

For the pit crews, go old school and give each crew 2 4-way lug wrenches instead of air guns to change the tires.

Bill B

Burn it! Burn it to the ground. And never look back.


I agree. 3 extra “all” stars race their way in and fans vote for another one. Look through the list of those racing the “3” open races, who is driving the best equipment !


Wreck him in the first open, mess Nascar’s plans up.


They’ll let him run his backup car after he gets the “fan vote.”




Two simple words: Iowa Speedway.




What to do with ASR——-CANCEL. waste of time and talent Give teams a week off. I’m certainly not going to watch.


Get rid of it,… Period. We definitely need more short tracks to race at, not more Road Courses. I think the all-star race has run it’s course…

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com