Race Weekend Central

Fire on Fridays: Here’s Who Should Replace Brad Keselowski in the No. 2

Brad Keselowski‘s foray into NASCAR Cup Series ownership seems to be a done deal, depending on who you ask.

And aside from the question of where Keselowski would fit in at Roush Fenway Racing — new car? Replacing an existing driver? — there’s also the case of his current ride, Team Penske’s No. 2.

Which is a car that’s going to exist next year, make no mistake there. When a driver’s subtracted from the fold at a team, there’s always the possibility of equivalent transfer in the age of charters, with the addition of a car somewhere meaning the removal of one elsewhere as charters change hands. And even if Keselowski’s potential departure means less charters in the Penske stable (this is not exactly something most folks are expecting, to be clear), the No. 2 would still exist. It’d just have to. As long as Penske continues fielding Cup cars, a Penske No. 2 carries far more tradition than the team’s Nos. 12 or 22.

The driver of the No. 2? That’s a different story entirely.

Generally there are three agreed-upon scenarios that seem the most likely, though. One’s an existing Penske driver sliding into the No. 2 — think Alex Bowman replacing Jimmie Johnson in the No. 48 at Hendrick Motorsports. Joey Logano‘s got quite the history in the No. 22 now, so it’s difficult to imagine him shifting to another car number. Ryan Blaney, on the other hand? His No. 12 tenure is far less substantial; moving from the tertiary car to a flagship could be in the cards.

But it’s thought to be more likely that the seat will come down to one of the two other competitors in the Penske or Penske-adjacent NASCAR world: Matt DiBenedetto or Austin Cindric.

DiBenedetto would be a clean shift. His two-season stint at Penske satellite Wood Brothers Racing is supposed to be over this year, and with a room opening up at the inn, he’d be an simple replacement for Keselowski, even if he lacks the star power of his predecessor in this scenario.

Then there’s Cindric. He’s the driver announced to replace DiBenedetto at WBR for his rookie Cup season in 2022, snagging a call-up from Penske’s Xfinity Series ranks. But unlike DiBenedetto, Cindric’s got the more explicit Penske connection; aside from the Xfinity role, he’s run a limited schedule for the team in Cup this year in its No. 33, and his dad’s the team president. It’s not terribly common, but it’s also not unheard of for previously announced plans to change by the time teams show up for the Daytona 500; would Cindric make more sense in the No. 2, while DiBenedetto stays put in the Woods’ No. 21?

The answer is yes, by the way. Cindric should get the No. 2.

Let’s address the nepotistic elephant in the room first: yeah, Cindric’d be getting the ride in part because Tim Cindric runs the show at Penske. But is that really all that bad a thing here? Not to say all offspring of team owners, presidents or even past NASCAR superstars should always get the look over someone who’s not — they shouldn’t. And if you’d posed the possibility of this eventually happening in 2015, when Cindric was first getting his feet wet in the Camping World Truck Series, I for one would’ve said hey, no, give it to DiBenedetto, Cindric’s just the president’s son.

See also
Truckin’ Thursdays: Ben Rhodes Talks Cup Debut at Sonoma, Truck Success

Despite a Truck career that produced a win but never quite set the racing world on far, though, Cindric’s actually become a force to be reckoned with in stock cars. Shoot, he won the 2020 Xfinity championship and he’s currently leading the 2021 standings. He boasts 11 wins entering Mid-Ohio Sports Car Course this weekend, where he’s a favorite for the victory. He’s gone from respectable at ovals and dynamite on road courses to a contender practically everywhere.

And yeah, he’s racing a Penske car, so he should most certainly be competing for wins. But Cindric’s championship, six-win 2020 and strong start to 2021 suggests he’s got more upside than your usual prospect with connections to the top brass — like, for instance, Austin Dillon, who won the 2013 Xfinity title with a no-win season and had just two series victories before being moved up to Cup. Dillon’s never exactly blown folks away at the sport’s top level, but he’s won some of the series’ biggest races and is at the very least generally considered worthy of a seat in Cup. If Cindric’s well ahead of those metrics already, it stands to reason that his success will carry over in some capacity to Cup, too.

To that end, why put him in a Wood Brothers car, then? Would that not just delay the inevitable? We’re not talking a guy who seems too concerned about making his own way; he drives for Penske now, so one can’t imagine him getting to Cup and deciding he’d rather forge his own path with another organization. Getting him in the No. 21 made sense when Penske didn’t necessarily have the space for him but didn’t want him just beating up on Xfinity regulars when he was clearly ready for the big time. But with the No. 2 potentially open, and Cindric’s future probably including a Penske Cup car at some point anyway, would it be better to put in someone who’ll, yes, be a rookie, but comes with a formidable-enough pedigree that he might challenge for a win here and there in said rookie season if he’s in equipment like Penske’s?

At 22, Cindric fits the bill as the young talent around which a team can build a dynasty. Can we say the same about DiBenedetto?

Full disclosure, DiBenedetto’s a great driver, and his story the past few years has been one of the more inspiring on the NASCAR national series level. He went from highly touted Joe Gibbs Racing prospect to start-and-parker for anyone who’d hire him to someone who’d regularly punch above his weight in underfunded Cup equipment, which landed him his WBR ride to begin with. And despite a fairly miserable start to the 2021 season, he’s started to get more into that 2019-2020 form that made him one of the sport’s beloved underdogs.

And hey, maybe there’s a chance DiBenedetto could be the next Bowman, a driver who did eventually get the shot with one of the elites and showed that his success elsewhere was no fluke. Who five years ago expected Bowman to be a four-time Cup winner and someone who can actually hold his own performance-wise at Hendrick, the series’ gold-standard team? Moving DiBenedetto to the No. 2 could very well be a similar move.

If Cindric was a year or two away from being Cup ready, then sure, give DiBenedetto the nod. The problem is he’s ready as is, and there’s also no guarantee DiBenedetto would be leaps and bounds better than Cindric in the same equipment.

See also
Ryan Newman Wants to Keep Racing Amid Brad Keselowski Ownership Rumors

Shoot, look at their 2021s. DiBenedetto’s got a 17.7 average finish in his 15 Cup starts this season. Cindric, in his five Cup races — and in his first experience with a Cup car in a race setting ever, mind you? A 22.4, which isn’t splashy but also isn’t too far off DiBenedetto’s average. Bear in mind, too, that their average finish would be almost identical had Cindric ended up in the top five two weekends ago at Circuit of the Americas, something that for a while seemed fairly possible after he started third and led the first four laps of the race. His eventual 25th-place finish was not indicative of his speed for much of the race.

Cindric may very well be the better driver, even if DiBenedetto’s got the experience. It seems like the better move to instead keep the latter in the No. 21, still part of the Penske family but not in a ride he might not have come 2023 or beyond anyway. Because, OK, let’s say Penske decides to go with DiBenedetto for next year. Does Cindric seem like the long-term answer for the No. 21? Not exactly. Maybe there’s a scenario where both of them end up at Penske thanks to a departing Blaney and/or Logano, but there are not yet whispers of such a transaction, so it’s difficult to even consider it just yet.

Penske and the Woods may decide to keep the status quo after Keselowski’s departure, going full steam ahead with the previous announcement that Cindric will run for rookie of the year in the No. 21 in 2022. Hell, the rumors of Keselowski’s move to Roush could even be greatly exaggerated.

But if Keselowski’s gone and Cindric and DiBenedetto are the two options to replace him, Cindric’s the right option, even if DiBenedetto might be the more popular decision. For Penske’s future, it just seems to make the most sense.

About the author

Rutherford is the managing editor of Frontstretch, a position he gained in 2015 after serving on the editing staff for two years. At his day job, he's a journalist covering music and rock charts at Billboard. He lives in New York City, but his heart is in Ohio -- you know, like that Hawthorne Heights song.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Carl D.

I have to agree. I’m a DeBenedetto fan, but Cindric is obviously a rising star, while Matty D. has a lower profile. Of course, the final decision will depend on who the #2 team sponsors want driving the car.


Done deal, Cindric gets the ride.

Al Cibelli

I don’t agree with keeping Matt D in the 21 or the 2 car, He’s a nice guy but being a nice guy doesn’t win races, he’s under performing in the 21 and the 2 car deserves a top notch drive

Jill P

I think Austin Cindric should get the #2 ride next year or the near future. He is a very talented driver in anything he has ever driven. It may be intimidating at first, but he’ll do all right.

Randell J Hall Jr

The seat should go to Josef Newgarden


“Despite a truck career that never set the racing world on fire”. What? He only did ONE year in trucks, where he made the Championship 4, won a race, and finished 3rd in points, beating out established truck drivers like Crafton etc. Not sure what else you can ask for from an 18 year old rookie who had very little stock car experience prior to that season in trucks. His Xfinity career has been phenomenal, and he’s already a Champion at that level, something that current Cup drivers Bell, Erik Jones, Briscoe and Custer were never able to accomplish. Cindric has far outperformed his expectations and I don’t think there’s any reason to even bring up “nepotism”. The reason he keeps moving up the latter is because he just keeps winning at every level. This is Roger Penske’s team, not Tim Cindric’s. If Penske didn’t want Cindric in the car then Cindric wouldn’t be in the car, period. Penske is the billionaire team owner, not Tim Cindric. Austin Cindric’s scenario is also no different than Chase Elliott. They both come from a family with a wealthy dad who helped fund their youth racing career. They both had the talent to prove they belong, and are both now going to be racing at the top level because of their talent. It’s as simple as that. If neither of them had talent, Rick Hendrick and Roger Penske would have gotten rid of them years ago. It’s funny though that nobody brings up nepotism when talking about Chase, who’s dad has wayyyy more money than Tim Cindric could dream of. Overall, good article but I don’t think it’s fair that everyone brings up nepotism as if that’s a reason Austin Cindric will be getting a Cup ride. Every single driver in this sport had a level of privilege which led them to the spot they’re at. And I personally would like to see Cindric go to the Wood Brothers as planned so he can help them get back to their winning ways. Cindric is a contender everywhere, but his road course talent is so far superior to his competitors that I see no reason why he won’t win a race as a rookie in the 21 car at one of the road courses, which would give the Wood Brothers their historic 100th Cup win which would be a great day for the sport. I’m wishing Cindric the best of luck with his career.


I’m not 100% sure of this but I believe the Cindric family was very wealthy in their own right. Maybe not Penske wealthy but much more so than the Elliott’s if I’m not mistaken?

Other than that I agree with what you are saying in principle. However we need to also keep in mind the only reason Wood bros and Penske can work together as closely as they do is because Penske is 3 car operation and the Woods 1. If either decide to field an additional car full time they won’t be allowed to collaborate as closely as they do now.

Come to think of it I’m not sure how that rule applies with a part time entry? That could explain Matty D’s slow start if they are barred from collaborating as closely as usual on weekends where the 33 is running?


I also doubt that the Elliott family has more money than the Cindric family. Bill’s success was in years when the purses and salaries were much less, plus he put a lot of his own money into the #94 car he drove for many years. Chase may have a higher net worth now than his father.

As for multi-car teams, NASCAR doesn’t seem to be bothered by alliances that exceed the 4-car limit. JGR ran 4 cars while also allied with Furniture Row Racing and the #78. And now JGR is allied with #23 and and Jordan-Hamlin are rumored to be adding a second car, which would make an alliance of 6 cars. I don’t think the 4-car rule has any impact on the Ford alliance of Penske and Wood Brothers.

Matt Griffin

I’d imagine the sponsors of the #2 ride would prefer Blaney and his status as one of the most prominent (and sellable) personalities in the sport. Cindric could then be placed behind the wheel of the #12. That’s my hope anyway?


I am with you on that bro, Blaney deserves that #2 ride.

Mike B

If you want a good driver who has a great personality and able to sell the product, then Matty D is and excellent choice. I don’t know if Matt has a lot more upside, but the 21 car has never been on the same level as Penske cars so it’s hard to figure. I’d like to see Matt at Penske for a year just to see if he has more of an upside, but I’d also like to see him keep his ride at WoodBR for a couple more years and spend at least one year not having to worry about the next year. I’d probably move Blaney to the #2 car and put Cindric in the 12.

Share via