During the offseason, NASCAR created a rule limiting Monster Energy NASCAR Cup Series drivers with five or more years experience to 10 XFINITY Series events per season. The hope was adding that in-season limit could allow more full-time regulars to run up front.
Instead? So far it’s same old, same old as Cup full-timers are running roughshod over the competition.
Three races into the 2017 season, there doesn’t appear to be much difference in the final results. Two of the first three XFINITY races have been won by Cup veterans (Kyle Busch at Atlanta Motor Speedway and Joey Logano at Las Vegas Motor Speedway).
At Daytona, three of the top-five finishers were Cup drivers; in Atlanta and Las Vegas, that number rose to four apiece. In fact, over the last two weeks only one series regular, JJ Yeley, has even led a lap.
That’s pushed the controversy of Cup drivers racing in NASCAR’s lower series back to the forefront. However, some XFINITY regulars still feel their presence is productive, believing it’s necessary to help them develop and improve their skills.
“I still like having the Cup guys in the races,” said Justin Allgaier, who finished fourth and the best among series regulars in Saturday’s Boyd Gaming 300. “Hats off to Kyle [Busch], Kyle [Larson], Joey [Logano, race winner], and Brad [Keselowski]. Those guys are phenomenal racecar drivers and to be up there racing them at the end … Kyle Busch and I had a great battle there that last restart.
“It’s just fun [to have them racing you]. They’re not going to get any extra room, but they’re going to race you clean and it makes it a lot of fun while you’re out there.”
Stewart-Haas Racing rookie Cole Custer also approves of facing Cup-tier competition. Custer, 19, finished 11th after qualifying 20th at Vegas and feels over time the rules will work themselves out.
“I think we definitely need to have them,” he explained. “But I think it’s good how NASCAR is limiting it for the amount of races they can do. I think they can limit it a little bit more, but they’ve definitely done a good job and we still need to be able to race them.
“I think it will be better racing and for the fans when it’s just us in the [playoffs], but it’s really good to be racing against Cup guys.”
Not all XFINITY contenders favor having Cup drivers competing against them, though. Blake Koch, who finished 12th at Vegas, said XFINITY events have just as good a show as Cup races and don’t need a higher level of talent for the series.
“Now more than ever, the Cup guys have a big advantage in these cars because they drive like Cup cars,” Koch claimed. He’s right; the XFINITY car’s new downforce package comes with the smaller rear spoilers. “They get double the amount of track time and they handle like a Cup car.
“Iowa [Speedway] always sells out and is a standalone. I never complain, but I’m just giving my opinion.”
Roush Fenway Racing’s Ryan Reed, who was the first XFINITY regular to win at the season opener in Daytona, feels his No. 16 team will grow to compete with the Cup guys over time. The 23-year-old California native finished ninth at the 1.5-mile track and thinks they’re closing on top teams with Cup regulars.
That includes fellow Ford Racing rival, Team Penske, which was the winning group in Saturday’s race. Penske fielded two XFINITY cars with 2012 Cup champion Keselowski and Logano, both of whom ran circles around their competition.
“We’re catching them,” Reed said, unfazed by the gap in speed. “Jack [Roush, team owner] said we’re in championship form right now, so we’re not going to give up. The gap is closing and if we close the gap every week by Homestead, we’ll be right where we need to be.”
That championship round is when NASCAR hopes the new rules will kick things up a notch, fully eliminating Cup veterans from competing while clearing the way for XFINITY talent. With the elimination-style format, plus race wins earning an automatic berth into the next round, it’s imperative for series regulars to run up front.
But that transition is still six months away. Will the new rules give XFINITY regulars the boost they need before then?
About the author
The Frontstretch Staff is made up of a group of talented men and women spread out all over the United States and Canada. Residing in 15 states throughout the country, plus Ontario, and widely ranging in age, the staff showcases a wide variety of diverse opinions that will keep you coming back for more week in and week out.
A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.