Race Weekend Central

2-Headed Monster: Is Justin Allgaier Making the Right Career Move?

Following his win at the Food City 300 last Friday (Sept. 15) at Bristol Motor Speedway, Justin Allgaier broke the news that he is returning to JR Motorsports in 2024.

There had been rumblings that Allgaier was leaving JRM and taking long-time sponsor Brandt with him. However, Allgaier promptly put an end to that speculation.

Having been a constant in the mid-tier series for almost 15 years (except for two years in the NASCAR Cup Series), is Allgaier making the right move remaining the opening act for the headlining Cup Series?

This week Steve Leffew and Andrew Stoddard breakdown the motivations and misgivings behind the decision in 2-Headed Monster.

Allgaier Making Correct Career Move

Allgaier has done well in the Xfinity Series, driving for JR Motorsports since 2016. With a long-running relationship with his sponsor Brandt and a resume full of success at the Xfinity level, Allgaier had to be on the short list for some of the openings in the Cup Series.

If you’re Matt Kaulig, who would you rather have driving the No. 31 Cup car, Daniel Hemric or Allgaier? Both drivers bring some funding. Allgaier is a proven winner, with 22 Xfinity wins and counting. Hemric has one win in all three national series. Kaulig probably wasn’t the only team that had interest in acquiring Allgaier to drive on Sundays. The opportunities in the Cup Series were not going to be good career moves for a driver who likely has less career in front of him than behind.

This was the right career move for more reasons than meet the eye.

Allgaier will turn 38 during the 2024 NASCAR season; he has two daughters, ages 10 and 2. The schedule in the Xfinity Series is more family friendly, with five additional off-weekends per season. Allgaier is a well-known family man who, back in 2021, said he would not miss the birth of his second child even if it meant being ruled ineligible for the playoffs.

The Xfinity Series gives him Sundays off and more weekends at home.

Who doesn’t love winning? At this stage in his career, Allgaier likely knows he isn’t going to be able to win a Cup championship in any ride available to him. By staying in the Xfinity Series and driving for JR Motorsports, he has a car capable of winning every weekend, and he has a great chance to become a champion.

See also
Dropping the Hammer: A Bubba Wallace Intro Song With Something To Say

The HScott Motorsports experience from 2014-15 provides a decent example of how a Cup effort with a team like Kaulig could go. In those years, his best finish in the standings was 29th and he scored one top 10 in 71 races. Ouch. In each of the last four seasons, Allgaier has finished fifth or better in points. With his win last weekend at Bristol, he has a real shot at a title again this season. ‘Little Gator’ made a career move that allows him to win a championship.

It’s not uncommon to hear fans and drivers say the best racing of the weekend comes courtesy of the Xfinity Series. The Next Gen Cup car has put on good racing at some tracks and lackluster racing at others. Allgaier has done well at just about every style of track lately, but he is particularly proficient at short tracks, flat tracks, and road courses. Coincidentally, those tracks seem to be putting on the poorest show in the Cup Series. By staying where he is, he gets to race in a series where his strengths can shine through.

In late July of this year, NASCAR announced a jaw-dropping seven-year deal for the Xfinity Series to be broadcast exclusively on the CW. The deal was reportedly worth $115 million per year, which is said to be nearly three times more lucrative than the Xfinity Series piece of the current deals with FOX and NBC Universal. This likely means more lucrative opportunities for drivers, and more exposure of their efforts, courtesy of the CW’s nationwide free availability.

Granted, Allgaier hasn’t announced any plans for 2025 and beyond yet, which is when the CW deal will begin, but he stands to benefit as much as anybody from this new deal is he keeps his place with a top-tier team into the new deal.

We’ve covered the benefits for family life. We’ve discussed the ability to win races and championships. We know about his prior forays into Cup and how those played out. We touched on the quality of racing in the Xfinity Series. The new deal that will help grow the series. What else could a driver want? Respect.

Allgaier is currently the most respected driver in the Xfinity Series. He races clean, he wins, and has been around the block. He has the talent to run with the top prospects who pass through on the way to the Cup Series and earns their respect on and off track. Check out this tweet from part-time Xfinity Series driver Brad Perez after Allgaier won at Bristol.

When I had a chance to sit down with Perez at Road America, he lauded Allgaier’s embrace of the mentor role in the series. When Perez failed to qualify for a race in 2022 at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway road course, he was shocked when Allgaier approached him to give a pep talk and some pointers. Perez didn’t think Allgaier even knew who he was, but yet there he was, offering support and encouragement. The mentorship of a big brother would be reduced to near-zero in the Cup Series, but in Xfinity, he is universally respected and looked up to.

Knowing all of this, why would he ever leave? – Steve Leffew

Allgaier Needs to Give the Cup Series One More Shot

While sticking with JRM and the Xfinity Series is not a bad career move for Allgaier, I do not think it was the best career move for the veteran driver.

With the exception of a championship, Allgaier has accomplished all he can in the Xfinity Series. He has won 22 races on a wide variety of tracks, collected 258 top-10 finishes in 432 starts (a 59.7% percentage), and finished in the top five in points eight of the last nine seasons. A perennial contender, fan favorite, and generally regarded as one of the “good guys” in the industry, Allgaier has all the tools to take the next step.

The stats speak loud and clear: Allgaier earned another shot at the Cup Series.  

Assuming Allgaier wanted to stay with Chevrolet, there were certainly some open Cup rides in the Bow Tie stable this silly season. The Kaulig Racing No. 31 team has shown flashes of competitiveness with Justin Haley, and while the Spire No. 77 has been a backmarker this season, the team elevated its game in the No. 7 with Corey LaJoie, particularly with new partner Gainbridge coming onboard to inject some much-needed capital into the equation. A new, steady veteran presence behind the wheel could be the secret ingredient for these teams to take a step forward, and Allgaier definitely fits that bill.

Furthermore, Allgaier brings something to the table that Cup Series owners crave: established sponsorship. Brandt has been with Allgaier through thick and thin since 2011, and Allgaier could have used that sponsorship as leverage to land a Cup Series contract. Bringing in a driver/sponsor combination with such a deep connection to each other would have been a boon for Cup Series teams seeking drivers.  

See also
Did You Notice?: RFK Racing Success Pushing Stewart-Haas Racing Out at Ford?

Now, those on the other side might argue that Allgaier had his chance at the Cup Series and did not do anything with it. Yes, Allgaier ran two full Cup Series seasons in 2014 and 2015 with only one top-10 finish, but that was in the phenomenally sub-par equipment of HScott Motorsports, a team that wound up folding the very next season in 2016. In my mind, that does not constitute a fair shake in the Cup Series.

That same car had Clint Bowyer questioning his life decisions in 2016.

Hypothetically, let us say that Allgaier takes a Cup ride, it does not go well, and he and the team part ways after two or three seasons. A quality Xfinity Series ride would be just one phone call away. JRM would likely welcome Allgaier back with open arms, or another top-flight Xfinity team like Kaulig Racing or Richard Childress Racing would sign him in a heartbeat.

Yes, Allgaier is a family man and the Xfinity Series schedule is more accommodating towards family time. But Allgaier is also something else: a competitor, and a competitor wants to race the best and beat the best.

Most argue that racecar drivers peak in their late thirties, and at 37 years old, Allgaier is smack in the middle of that age bracket, no baggage and in the prime of his racing life. Now would have been as good a time as any to make one last leap to the Cup Series. If Allgaier had taken a Cup Series ride, I could have easily seen him competing for a playoff spot in 2024. – Andrew Stoddard

About the author

Steve Leffew joined Frontstretch in 2023, and covers the Xfinity Series. He resides in Wisconsin and has been a NASCAR fan as long as he can remember. He has served honorably in the United States Air Force and works during the week as a Real Estate Lender.

Andrew Stoddard joined Frontstretch in May of 2022 as an iRacing contributor. He is a graduate of Hampden-Sydney College, the University of Richmond, and VCU. He has a new day job as an athletic communications specialist at Eastern Mennonite University in Harrisonburg, Va.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sally Baker

Obviously he has found a ‘happy place’ at JRM. His value with mentoring young drivers is immense. It used to be that many drivers were happy to stay in the ‘lower’ series, finding the less pressure of time and success a more enjoyable experience. Good for Justin. Hope he finally gets that well deserved title this year.


i suspect he’s very happy at jrm. i’m sure he has input into some things at jrm since he is the “elder statesman” of the organization when it comes to their driver pool. like was mentioned he has sundays off, unless he’s subbing for someone, and seems very content where he is. plus he knows his equipment. cup is the horrid car that they are still struggling with 2 years in.

i know jeff and david green both were in xfinity (busch) series, and had opportunities in cup, but they’re remembered for their time in xfinity, same thing for randy lajoie.

sometimes people are content where they are and are challenged enough. his sponsor gets lots of coverage, so i imagine they’er happy too.

Kevin in SoCal

“Hemric has one win in all three national series.”

Hemric has a Cup win? Or what did you mean here? ARCA, Trucks, XFINITY? I’m thinking you meant one win in all three series combined. Not one win in each series.


Big fish in a small pond or small fish in a big pond? Where has he got a better chance to win?

Tim Childers

This headline is a clickbaiting misnomer. This is not a “career move”…..just the opposite. He’s not moving anywhere, and it’s because Justin, Brandt, Junior, and Kelley all know they’ve got a great thing just like it is. There are still a few career Xfinity drivers, and that’s still a good thing.


Both Allgaier and his current team are in a very good place. He has helped many drivers succeed. His long time sponsors followed him to Cup before. They know the financial increment. I suspect he is well compensated. He’s 38 with, per statistics, 5 more years to learn a completely different car. His best move is to stay put and ride out his current success for as long as the sponsor, the owner and he are happy.


This is all bullshit
…you guys sit around and think up stuff to get you headlines …click on your site…
Justin has been pretty committed to JR and definitely is in the running for a championship with his present situation…why would he leave!!

Share via