Race Weekend Central

It’s Time for Justice for Bobby Allison

In the 75 years of the NASCAR Cup Series, there is just one race without an official winner.

Bobby Allison took the checkered flag first in the 1971 Myers Brothers 250 at Bowman Gray Stadium on Aug. 6, 1971. But the NASCAR Hall of Famer was never credited with the win.

If you look at Racing Reference’s page on Allison, he is credited with 84 career Cup wins. It says he had 10 wins in the 1971 season. But if you open up the page on that season, you can count 11 times he finished first that year.

On the race page for the 1971 Myers Brothers 250, it has Allison listed in first and Richard Petty second. Yet Allison still isn’t credited with the win.

So why doesn’t NASCAR count the race as a win for Allison? There was no scoring dispute despite them being quite common at the time. Allison was not black flagged, and his Ford Mustang passed post-race inspection. There have been cars that won races in way shadier conditions where the team got to keep the race win.

The problem started because NASCAR fielded a Grand American series from 1968-71, which was a circuit just for pony cars such as Allison’s Mustang. When the Cup field was on the light side, NASCAR would fill the field by having a combination race.

See also
Frontstretch 5: Greatest Moments From the 2023 Season

So while the Mustang usually wouldn’t be allowed in a Cup race, it was in these combination races, and this Bowman Gray race was one of them. Petty’s Plymouth was the first finisher of the Cup-allowed cars, so it would make sense to give him credit for the victory and set his career total at 201 wins. But that never happened either.

Plus giving Petty that win would open a whole other can of worms because of Tiny Lund. Lund won two of those combination races in a Chevrolet Camaro, another car used in the Grand American tour and not Cup. So if Petty were credited with the Bowman Gray win, two of Lund’s five career Cup wins should be taken away and given to the second-place finisher in those two combination races: Elmo Langley in a Ford at Hickory Speedway and Charlie Glotzbach in a Chevy at North Wilkesboro Speedway.

I can’t imagine NASCAR taking the wins away from Lund, and it quite honestly wouldn’t be right to do so more than 50 years after the wins and after his passing in 1975.

But why do those wins in Grand American cars count for Lund but not for Allison? I could understand if they happened in different years and the rules were different then, but they literally happened the same season.

I get it, the debate to give Allison his 85th win has been ongoing ever since the race happened 52 years ago. But the issue was brought to light again when the X (formerly Twitter) account @BobbyWon85 posted on Nov. 4 that they asked NASCAR President Steve Phelps and COO Steve O’Donnell about crediting Allison with the Bowman Gray win.

“Tonight I talked to both Steve O’Donnell and @stevephelps from @NASCAR about recognizing Bobby Allison’s 85th win,” @BobbyWon85 wrote. “O’Donnell sent himself an email and said they would discuss in the offseason. Phelps was less committed, and said, ‘That happened a long time ago.’”

You can’t believe everything you read on the Internet, especially on X. And we don’t even know who runs that account, so we don’t even know if those conversations actually took place. Those responses feel real to me, though, so let’s continue as if they’re accurate.

O’Donnell’s response was the correct one, and I hope he and his team really do look into it over the offseason.

Phelps’ response, on the other hand, is wrong on so many levels.

Saying “that happened a long time ago” is the response you’d expect from a frat bro as an excuse not to learn in his history class, not the president of the biggest motorsports brand in the country.

See also
Stat Sheet: A Statistical Summary of the 2023 Cup Season

I can’t find Phelps’ exact age, but according to ESPN, he is 60 or 61 years old. So his birth took place more than eight years before the Myers Brothers 250, so I guess that makes him something “that happened a long time ago” too and should likewise be ignored.

Who cares that the race took place 52 years ago? As the @BobbyWon85 account said in the replies, “It’s never too late to do the right thing.”

Plus, if I were president of a sports league, I certainly would want to do the best of my abilities to make sure that all of the records were complete. As long as one Cup race doesn’t have a winner, NASCAR’s record book is incomplete.

Giving Allison an 85th career win would break his tie for fourth on the all-time Cup wins list with Darrell Waltrip. It’s a huge deal to be in the top 10 on the all-time wins list, and we’ve seen legends like Rusty Wallace and Lee Petty fall out of that list in recent years. As active drivers like Kyle Busch, Denny Hamlin, Joey Logano and Kyle Larson as well as those who come after them move up the all-time wins list, Allison’s spot would be that much safer with an 85th win and sole possession of his spot.

NASCAR can’t forget about its history and its legends, especially one like Allison who poured everything he had into the sport. Aside from his Hall of Fame driving career, he owned a team, won the Most Popular Driver award seven times, lost a part of his memory and nearly died in a career-ending crash and lost two sons who were competing in NASCAR. Despite the tragedies and despite being 85 years old and barely being able to walk, Allison still comes to several NASCAR races and is a great spokesman for the series.

Just four years ago, I saw Allison at the now-defunct Southside Speedway near Richmond, Va. He came all that way to a tiny, struggling short track just to meet fans, take pictures with them and sign autographs. What a great ambassador and legend.

If not for Allison’s fight with Cale Yarborough after the 1979 Daytona 500, the first Daytona 500 that was televised flag-to-flag, NASCAR may never have experienced the boom in popularity that followed. He was a star in NASCAR when it mattered the most, and he sure deserves that 85th win.

So do the right thing, NASCAR. Myself and many others demand justice for Allison. We don’t know how much longer he’ll be around, so can you please do it while we still have him? Give him his 85th career win.

About the author

Michael.massie 113x150

Michael Massie joined Frontstretch in 2017 and has served as the Content Director since 2020. Massie, a Richmond, Va., native, has covered NASCAR, IndyCar, SRX and the CARS Tour. Outside of motorsports, the Virginia Tech grad and Green Bay Packers minority owner can be seen cheering on his beloved Hokies and Packers.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

25 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
DoninAjax

If it makes sense, NA$CAR won’t consider it.

Here is the race page:

http://www.racing-reference.info/race/1971_Myers_Brothers_250/W

NASCAR held a race and nobody won it.

Echo

lololol Nascar wonders why ratings keep dropping. Nobody won, amazing Brian. I know he’s still around, has to be.

John

It took over 50 years to give Wendell Scott’s next of kin the trophy he won. If Lund was credited with wins in similar circumstances, I’m not sure how that doesn’t define this completely. And it doesn’t take a win away from Petty, (although several should be). Who was paid first place money? They certainly were the winner.

RCFX1

Wasn’t there a Waltrip/Allison win controversy? Massa wants to rewrite history after 15 years. Do we give Rudd the Sonoma trophy since he actually won the race? Where does it end?

Duane

Rudd did win Sonoma. Rudd and Alison got together on a racing incident. Earnhardt famously “rattled Labontes cage” and blatantly took Terry out at Bristol and kept the win. These incidents and Bobby’s is why most times Nascar is a clown show. Why do people even think Nascar has any credibility.

Dav_Daddy

NASCAR has a lot more credibility than F1 so must not be that bad off.

NASCAR never had a race director wipe his backside with the rulebook to hand his preferred driver an undeserved title. Also no joke of a “super license” nor do they let media rights holders dictate which teams are allowed on the grid.

Echo

F-1 Vegas tomorrow. 1 year ago certain grandstand tickets went on sale for 10 grand. Nobody would pay that in Nascar. 100,000 expected for Vegas race. Does Nascar get 10,000. F1 markets itself well. Nascar just screws up and slides downhill. And I don’t like or watch f1

Craig P.

Nascar is run by a bunch of jackasses!!! That’s why I stopped going to the races and watching on TV!

Sean

When the Wood Bros were denied a charter was my FU Nascar moment.

JD in NC

100% agree. There is no plausible reason why Bobby Allison should not be credited with this win. It’s time to finally fix it.

David

Why did you include Hamlin, Lagono, & Larson, with Kyle Busch when talking about “moving into the top 10” ?? Only K.B. is in the top 10, the others not close. But you did forget Kevin Harvick, who IS in the top 10, on your list.

Lawrence

Today nascar is joke. Management is just dumb. Left nascar long ago. Attend a few dirt races. Never spend another dime on nascar.

Joshua Farmer

Fairweather fans not wanted.

Sam

Well they should give it to him however when they open that door there is a race that waltrip can argue that he won and I don’t remember but I think allison is credited for winning so they would still be tied with 84 or tied with 85

Kevin

Completely different circumstances

Last edited 7 months ago by Kevin
Todd

How can we help? Seems like a great injustice…

Cindy Lewis

You are so right!! Do the right thing Nascar. Make good for Bobby who so deserves it. He has done so much for Nascar, so do the right thing!!!!

Tcob 63

Nascar lost all my respect with this generic car of tomorrow. Where do these asswipes get the idea that they can out design a car manufacturer. Case in point cars catching fire , center nut like f1 but these keep falling off , stage racing. It’s all a joke. Only difference in all the cars is a highly restricted motor and the nut behind the wheel. These ceased to be stock cars a long time ago.

Tom Schoon

It’s nothing but a ‘spec’ car series, different bodies everything else the same…… that’s why they have to put the the grill and head and tailight stickers on the cars so you can tell them apart!
🤭👎😅🤣😤

William Benefiel

Give him the win. He won the race and deserves to be credited with it. Nascar needs to smarten up real soon.

Bernice Ouellette

If not for the Allison’s live career in NASCAR. NASCAR would not exist. Give Bobby what he deserves. Give him the WIN!

Kevin

This is different than any of the “so and so really won such and such race” Just like Petty and the oversized engine at Charlotte should have resulted in a disqualification and Allison in 2nd should have been awarded the win. This race at Bowman Gray was a Cup race without a winner. The only one ever. But Lund is credited with his wins in the exact same circumstances. No sense at all. It is the initial result of Bobby’s relationship with Big Bill during the early 70s, and now is because of the tie with racer turned popular TV announcer Waltrip. If Bobby was not tied with Waltrip they would give it to him IMO.

DoninAjax

Bobby is in a FORD. Tiny is in a CHEV.

Bobby is in a FORD. DW is in a CHEV.

Last edited 7 months ago by DoninAjax
Terry

NASCAR won’t give it to him because he drove aFORD they are only partial to chevy. That is why tiny Lund got credit for his because he was driving a Chevy

Mike

Bobby did not fight Cale. It was brother Donnie.

Share via